-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 31
fix: prevent panic in stakerInfo by passing correct *bind.CallOpts type #1278
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
fix: prevent panic in stakerInfo by passing correct *bind.CallOpts type #1278
Conversation
PR Compliance Guide 🔍Below is a summary of compliance checks for this PR:
Compliance status legend🟢 - Fully Compliant🟡 - Partial Compliant 🔴 - Not Compliant ⚪ - Requires Further Human Verification 🏷️ - Compliance label |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Overall Summary 🚀
Houston, we have a successful fix! This PR addresses a critical runtime panic caused by a type mismatch in reflection-based contract calls. The solution is precise and targeted - changing opts to &opts to pass the correct pointer type. Nice catch on this one, astronaut! ✨
General Feedback:
- The fix is solid and directly addresses the root cause identified in issue #1277.
- However, I noticed this pattern appears elsewhere in the codebase. We should audit similar usages to prevent this issue from occurring in other functions.
- Consider adding a note in the code or documentation about the reflection requirement for
*bind.CallOptsto help future maintainers.
Specific Code Comments:
File: utils/struct-utils.go - Line: 4 - Code: returnedValues := InvokeFunctionWithTimeout(stakeManager, "Maturities", &opts, big.NewInt(int64(index)))
✨ Perfect fix! Passing &opts instead of opts correctly provides the *bind.CallOpts pointer type that the contract binding expects. This will eliminate the reflection panic. Great debugging work! 🛰️
Critical Observations:
🔥 Important Follow-up Required: I see this same function InvokeFunctionWithTimeout is likely used throughout the codebase with contract bindings. Based on the error pattern, there may be other locations where opts is passed by value instead of by pointer.
💡 Recommendation: Run a codebase-wide search for InvokeFunctionWithTimeout calls to ensure all invocations pass &opts rather than opts. This could be lurking in other commands too!
File: utils/struct-utils.go - Line: 1 - Code: func (s StakeManagerStruct) GetMaturity(client *ethclient.Client, age uint32) (uint16, error) {
💡 Since this was a subtle bug, consider adding a comment above the InvokeFunctionWithTimeout call explaining why the pointer is necessary:
// Note: Must pass &opts (pointer) as contract bindings expect *bind.CallOpts
returnedValues := InvokeFunctionWithTimeout(stakeManager, "Maturities", &opts, big.NewInt(int64(index)))Reviewed Files:
utils/struct-utils.go
Positive Notes:
- 🎯 Laser-focused fix that directly addresses the panic without unnecessary changes
- ✅ Proper testing performed to verify the fix works end-to-end
- 📝 Excellent issue documentation with clear reproduction steps and error logs
- 🔍 Good use of debug logging throughout the execution flow
Additional Suggestions:
InvokeFunctionWithTimeout makes these type mismatches easy to introduce and hard to catch at compile time. Consider:
- Adding runtime type assertion checks inside
InvokeFunctionWithTimeoutto provide clearer error messages - Or refactoring to use typed function signatures where possible to leverage compile-time type checking
💡 Testing Enhancement: While manual testing is great, consider adding a unit test that specifically exercises this code path to prevent regression. Something like:
func TestGetMaturity_NoReflectionPanic(t *testing.T) {
// Test that GetMaturity doesn't panic with reflection errors
// This would have caught the bug before production
}Mission Status: ✅ CLEARED FOR LAUNCH
This fix is ready to merge! Just keep an eye out for similar patterns elsewhere in the codebase. Safe travels through the cosmos, fellow code explorer! 🌌🚀
Review generated by: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5
PR Code Suggestions ✨No code suggestions found for the PR. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Overall Summary 🚀
Houston, we have a fix! 🛰️ This PR successfully resolves a critical runtime panic caused by a type mismatch in reflection calls. The change is minimal, surgical, and directly addresses the root cause identified in issue #1277.
General Feedback:
- The fix is spot-on - changing
optsto&optscorrectly aligns with the contract binding's expectations for*bind.CallOpts. ✨ - Consider auditing other similar patterns in the codebase to prevent this issue from appearing elsewhere.
- The error logs and reproduction steps in the linked issue are excellent for debugging context!
Specific Code Comments:
File: utils/struct-utils.go - Line: 4 - Code: returnedValues := InvokeFunctionWithTimeout(stakeManager, "Maturities", &opts, big.NewInt(int64(index)))
💡 Perfect fix! The address-of operator (&opts) now passes a pointer to bind.CallOpts instead of the value, matching what the generated contract bindings expect via reflection. This prevents the reflect: Call using bind.CallOpts as type *bind.CallOpts panic. Nice catch! 🎯
Reviewed Files:
utils/struct-utils.go
Critical Observations:
🔥 Consistency Check Required:
While this PR fixes GetMaturity, I'd recommend scanning the entire codebase for similar patterns. Check if other methods in StakeManagerStruct or related structs are passing opts by value instead of by pointer to InvokeFunctionWithTimeout. This could be a systemic issue lurking in other commands.
Suggested search pattern:
InvokeFunctionWithTimeout(.*opts[^&])
The manual testing described is great, but consider adding a regression test that:
- Calls
GetMaturityprogrammatically - Verifies it doesn't panic
- Validates the returned maturity value
This would prevent future refactoring from reintroducing the bug.
Positive Notes:
- Single-line fix for a critical bug - that's efficient engineering! 🛰️
- The PR description is thorough with excellent reproduction steps and a helpful mermaid diagram
- The error message in the panic was clear enough to identify the exact issue - good Go reflection error handling
- The fix aligns perfectly with Go's idiomatic use of pointers for optional parameters (which
bind.CallOptsessentially is)
Mission Status: ✅ APPROVED FOR LIFTOFF
This is a clean, targeted bugfix that resolves a runtime crash. The change is correct and necessary. Just make sure to sweep the rest of the codebase for similar issues before declaring full mission success! 🚀✨
Review generated by: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5
User description
Description
This PR fixes a runtime panic in the stakerInfo command caused by passing an incorrect argument type to contract binding methods when invoking them via reflection.
The contract bindings expect
*bind.CallOpts, but the code was passingbind.CallOptsas a value, resulting in a reflection panic at runtime.Fixes #1277
How Has This Been Tested?
Reproduced the panic locally using:
Verified that the command now completes successfully without panicking and confirmed correct staker information is returned
PR Type
Bug fix
Description
Fix runtime panic in GetMaturity by passing pointer to bind.CallOpts
Contract bindings expect *bind.CallOpts, not value type
Corrects reflection invocation argument type mismatch
Diagram Walkthrough
File Walkthrough
struct-utils.go
Pass pointer to bind.CallOpts in GetMaturityutils/struct-utils.go
optsto&optsin InvokeFunctionWithTimeout call withinGetMaturity method
contract binding expectations
reflection