USHIFT-6438: Greenboot healthcheck service restart replacement

test/assets/auto-recovery/microshift-auto-recovery

@@ -5,22 +5,11 @@ set -xeuo pipefail
 # boot_success=0 is set when deployment is staged or when grub boots the system.
 # boot_success=1 is set when greenboot succeeds after deploying new image.
 
-# At this time we cannot depend on missing boot_counter meaning system is done with the "deployment testing & rebooting"
-# because of a bug in greenboot: set-success tries to clear boot_counter from wrong grub env file.
-if grep -q  "/boot/grubenv" /usr/libexec/greenboot/greenboot-grub2-set-success; then
-    if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_success=0; then
-        echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
-        echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
-        exit 0
-    fi
-else
-    # greenboot-grub2-set-success uses correct path.
-    # When the deployment testing is done, boot_counter should be removed.
-    if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_counter=; then
-        echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
-        echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
-        exit 0
-    fi
+# When the deployment testing is done, boot_counter should be removed.
+if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_counter=; then
+    echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
+    echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
+    exit 0
 fi
 
 /usr/bin/microshift restore --auto-recovery /var/lib/microshift-auto-recovery

test/assets/auto-recovery/red-script.sh

@@ -5,22 +5,11 @@ set -xeuo pipefail
 # boot_success=0 is set when deployment is staged or when grub boots the system.
 # boot_success=1 is set when greenboot succeeds after deploying new image.
 
-# At this time we cannot depend on missing boot_counter meaning system is done with the "deployment testing & rebooting"
-# because of a bug in greenboot: set-success tries to clear boot_counter from wrong grub env file.
-if grep -q  "/boot/grubenv" /usr/libexec/greenboot/greenboot-grub2-set-success; then
-    if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_success=0; then
-        echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
-        echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
-        exit 0
-    fi
-else
-    # greenboot-grub2-set-success uses correct path.
-    # When the deployment testing is done, boot_counter should be removed.
-    if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_counter=; then
-        echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
-        echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
-        exit 0
-    fi
+# When the deployment testing is done, boot_counter should be removed.
+if grub2-editenv - list | grep -q ^boot_counter=; then
+    echo "Greenboot didn't decide the system is healthy after staging new deployment."
+    echo "Quiting to not interfere with the process"
+    exit 0
 fi
 
 echo "System is unhealthy and greenboot's 'deployment testing' procedure is not active - running auto-recovery for MicroShift"

test/resources/microshift-host.resource

@@ -57,9 +57,11 @@ Reboot MicroShift Host
     SSHLibrary.Start Command    reboot    sudo=True
     Sleep    30s
 
-    Wait Until Keyword Succeeds    5m    15s
+    ${cur_bootid}=    Wait Until Keyword Succeeds    5m    15s
     ...    System Should Be Rebooted    ${bootid}
 
+    RETURN    ${cur_bootid}
+
 Create Thin Storage Pool
     [Documentation]    Create a new thin storage pool
     ${lvmd_vg}=    Set Variable If    '${LVMD_VG_OVERRIDE}' != ''    ${LVMD_VG_OVERRIDE}    rhel
@@ -107,9 +109,11 @@ System Should Not Be Ostree
 System Should Be Rebooted
     [Documentation]    Assert if the system rebooted comparing the current and provided boot identifier
     [Arguments]    ${old_bootid}
-    ${rebooted}=    Is System Rebooted    ${old_bootid}
+    ${rebooted}    ${cur_bootid}=    Is System Rebooted    ${old_bootid}
     Should Be True    ${rebooted}
 
+    RETURN    ${cur_bootid}
+
 Is System Rebooted
     [Documentation]    Check if the system rebooted comparing the current and provided boot identifier
     [Arguments]    ${old_bootid}
@@ -118,10 +122,10 @@ Is System Rebooted
     ${cur_bootid}=    Get Current Boot Id
     ${len}=    Get Length    ${cur_bootid}
     IF    ${len} == 0
-        RETURN    False
+        RETURN    False    ${old_bootid}
     ELSE
         ${system_rebooted}=    Evaluate    '${old_bootid}' != '${cur_bootid}'
-        RETURN    ${system_rebooted}
+        RETURN    ${system_rebooted}    ${cur_bootid}
     END
 
 Change Hostname

test/resources/ostree-health.resource

@@ -19,18 +19,14 @@ Greenboot Health Check Exited
     Systemctl Check Service SubState    greenboot-healthcheck.service    exited
 
 Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
-    [Documentation]    Restart the greenboot-healthcheck service and check its status
+    [Documentation]    Verify the health of the deployments using the MicroShift healthcheck command
+    [Arguments]    ${wait_timeout}=600s
 
-    VAR    ${unit_name}    greenboot-healthcheck.service
-
-    # Note that the Systemctl keyword from systemd.resource cannot be used to
-    # restart the greenboot-healthcheck service due to the keyword expecting
-    # the 'running' state after the restart. This condition does not apply on
-    # services like greenboot that exit after their startup finishes.
+    # Note that the newer implementation of greenboot-healthcheck service no
+    # longer allows service restart. Using the MicroShift healthcheck command
+    # to verify the health of the deployments.
     ${stdout}    ${stderr}    ${rc}    Execute Command
-    ...    systemctl restart ${unit_name}
+    ...    microshift healthcheck -v=2 --timeout="${wait_timeout}"
     ...    sudo=True    return_stdout=True    return_stderr=True    return_rc=True
-    IF    ${rc} != 0    Systemctl Print Service Status And Logs    ${unit_name}
+    IF    ${rc} != 0    Log Many    ${stdout}    ${stderr}
     Should Be Equal As Integers    0    ${rc}
-
-    Wait Until Greenboot Health Check Exited

test/suites/backup/auto-recovery-extra.robot

@@ -44,7 +44,6 @@ Using Systemd Dropin To React On Failure Of MicroShift
 Auto Recovery On Red Boot
     [Documentation]    Verify greenboot integration to start auto-recovery procedure.
 
-    Greenboot Workaround For Boot Counter
     Command Should Work    rm -rf ${SAFETY_BACKUP}
 
     Stop MicroShift
@@ -55,10 +54,13 @@ Auto Recovery On Red Boot
     Corrupt Etcd Database
     Start MicroShift Expecting Failure
 
-    ${bootid}=    Get Current Boot Id
-    Command Should Fail    systemctl restart greenboot-healthcheck
-    Wait Until Keyword Succeeds    5m    15s
-    ...    System Should Be Rebooted    ${bootid}
+    # Reboot to trigger greenboot auto-recovery, saving the boot identifier
+    ${cur_bootid}=    Reboot MicroShift Host
+    # The auto-recovery procedure will reboot the system after restoring the backup
+    ${new_bootid}=    Wait Until Keyword Succeeds    5m    15s
+    ...    System Should Be Rebooted    ${cur_bootid}
+    Should Not Be Equal As Strings    ${cur_bootid}    ${new_bootid}
+    # Verify the system is healthy after auto-recovery
     Wait Until Greenboot Health Check Exited
 
     [Teardown]    Run Keywords
@@ -157,9 +159,3 @@ Set Up Greenboot Red Script
     Command Should Work    mkdir -p /etc/greenboot/red.d
     ${drop_in}=    Operating System.Get File    ./assets/auto-recovery/red-script.sh
     Upload String To File    ${drop_in}    /etc/greenboot/red.d/99-auto-recovery.sh
-
-Greenboot Workaround For Boot Counter
-    [Documentation]    If the grub's boot_success is 1, clears boot_counter.
-    # Because of greenboot's bug, we need to it here, so the system doesn't reboot after red boot.
-    Command Should Work
-    ...    bash -c "grub2-editenv list | grep -q boot_success=1 && /usr/bin/grub2-editenv /boot/grub2/grubenv unset boot_counter || true"

test/suites/fault-tests/outages.robot

@@ -39,8 +39,9 @@ Network Disconnection
     Local Command Should Work    ${STRESS_TESTING_SCRIPT} -d network_outage ${STRESS_TESTING_REMOTE_FLAGS}
 
     # Check results
-    ${system_rebooted}=    Is System Rebooted    ${old_bootid}
+    ${system_rebooted}    ${cur_bootid}=    Is System Rebooted    ${old_bootid}
     Should Not Be True    ${system_rebooted}
+    Should Not Be Equal As Strings    ${cur_bootid}    ${old_bootid}
     Wait For MicroShift
     All Pods Should Be Running    timeout=600s
 

test/suites/greenboot/greenboot.robot

@@ -16,15 +16,16 @@ Test Tags           restart    slow
 ${LOCAL_WORKLOAD_FILE}          ../docs/config/busybox_running_check.sh
 ${GREENBOOT_WORKLOAD_FILE}      /etc/greenboot/check/required.d/50_busybox_running_check.sh
 ${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_FILE}        /etc/greenboot/greenboot.conf
-${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_CONTENT}     MICROSHIFT_WAIT_TIMEOUT_SEC=180
+${WAIT_TIMEOUT}                 180
+${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_CONTENT}     MICROSHIFT_WAIT_TIMEOUT_SEC=${WAIT_TIMEOUT}
 ${MANIFEST_SOURCE_DIR}          ./assets/kustomizations/greenboot/
 ${MANIFEST_DIR}                 /etc/microshift/manifests
-${HOSTNAME_BIN_PATH}            ""
+${HOSTNAME_BIN_PATH}            /usr/bin/hostname
 
 
 *** Test Cases ***
 Run with User Workload
-    [Documentation]    Add user's workload and verify that the workload starts and greenboot is successful.
+    [Documentation]    Add a user workload, verify that it starts and greenboot is successful
     Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
     Add User Workload
     Cleanup And Start
@@ -38,11 +39,12 @@ Simulate Service Failure
     Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
     Disrupt Service
     Cleanup MicroShift    --all    --keep-images
-    # not using 'Start MicroShift' kw because it retries
+    # Not using the 'Start MicroShift' keyword because it retries
     Run Keyword And Expect Error    0 != 1
     ...    Systemctl    start    microshift
+    # Lower the default wait timeout to fail-fast tests
     Run Keyword And Expect Error    0 != 1
-    ...    Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
+    ...    Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success    ${WAIT_TIMEOUT}s
 
     [Teardown]    Run Keywords
     ...    Restore Service
@@ -53,8 +55,9 @@ Simulate Pod Failure
     Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
     Disrupt Pod Network
     Restart MicroShift
+    # Lower the default wait timeout to fail-fast tests
     Run Keyword And Expect Error    0 != 1
-    ...    Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
+    ...    Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success    ${WAIT_TIMEOUT}s
 
     [Teardown]    Run Keywords
     ...    Remove Drop In MicroShift Config    10-svcNetwork
@@ -68,7 +71,8 @@ Setup Suite
     Check Required Env Variables
     Login MicroShift Host
     Setup Kubeconfig
-    Upload String To File    ${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_CONTENT}    ${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_FILE} # change the default timeout
+    # Change the default timeout to fail-fast tests
+    Upload String To File    ${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_CONTENT}    ${GREENBOOT_CONFIG_FILE}
 
 Add User Workload
     [Documentation]    Upload User workload files to the MicroShift host
@@ -92,7 +96,7 @@ Cleanup User Workload
     Should Be Equal As Integers    0    ${rc}
 
 Disrupt Service
-    [Documentation]    Prevent Microshift service from starting correctly.
+    [Documentation]    Prevent MicroShift service from starting correctly
 
     ${stdout}    ${rc}=    Execute Command
     ...    which hostname
@@ -109,18 +113,14 @@ Disrupt Service
     Should Be Equal As Integers    0    ${rc}
 
 Restore Service
-    [Documentation]    Restore Microshift service to the correct form.
+    [Documentation]    Restore MicroShift service to the correct form
     ${stdout}    ${rc}=    Execute Command
     ...    chmod 755 ${HOSTNAME_BIN_PATH}
     ...    sudo=True    return_rc=True
     Should Be Equal As Integers    0    ${rc}
 
-    # Reboot to regain ostree deployment (revert usroverlay)
-    ${is_ostree}=    Is System OSTree
-    IF    ${is_ostree}    Reboot MicroShift Host
-
 Disrupt Pod Network
-    [Documentation]    Prevent Microshift pods From starting correctly
+    [Documentation]    Prevent MicroShift pods from starting correctly
     ${configuration}=    Catenate    SEPARATOR=\n
     ...    network:
     ...    \ clusterNetwork:
@@ -131,8 +131,8 @@ Disrupt Pod Network
     Drop In MicroShift Config    ${configuration}    10-svcNetwork
 
 Cleanup And Start
-    [Documentation]    Wipe Microshift data and start it.
+    [Documentation]    Wipe MicroShift data and restart the system
     Cleanup MicroShift    --all    --keep-images
-    Start MicroShift
-    Setup Kubeconfig
-    Restart Greenboot And Wait For Success
+    Enable MicroShift
+    Reboot MicroShift Host
+    Wait Until Greenboot Health Check Exited

test/suites/tuned/microshift-tuned.robot

@@ -98,5 +98,6 @@ Restart MicroShift-Tuned Not Expecting Reboot
     Command Should Work    systemctl restart microshift-tuned.service
     Wait Until Keyword Succeeds    1m    10s
     ...    Systemctl Check Service SubState    microshift-tuned.service    dead
-    ${rebooted}=    Is System Rebooted    ${bootid}
+    ${rebooted}    ${cur_bootid}=    Is System Rebooted    ${bootid}
     Should Not Be True    ${rebooted}
+    Should Not Be Equal As Strings    ${cur_bootid}    ${bootid}