Comprehensive protocol compliance gap analysis and implementation roadmap

[Copilot]

Systematic assessment of ObjectQL's 19 packages against ObjectStack protocol specification. Current implementation is ~80% complete with critical architecture violations in protocol layer.

Documents Added

PROTOCOL_GAP_ANALYSIS.md (766 lines, bilingual CN/EN)

• Architecture compliance analysis across 5 layers (Foundation, Drivers, Protocols, Runtime, Tools)
• Feature matrix: 50+ capabilities evaluated
• 10 prioritized issues with fix proposals
• 4-phase remediation plan (6 weeks, 42 days effort)

NEXT_STEPS_ACTION_PLAN.md (600+ lines)

• Executable implementation guide with file-level changes
• Complete code examples for RuntimePlugin interface and ObjectStackRuntimeProtocol bridge
• Production-safe Redis permission storage (SCAN not KEYS)
• Phase-gated success criteria and risk mitigation

ASSESSMENT_SUMMARY_CN.md (300+ lines)

• Chinese executive summary for stakeholders
• Scoring matrix by dimension
• Week 1 immediate action items

Critical Findings

Architecture Non-Compliance (Urgent)

• Protocol plugins (GraphQL, OData V4, JSON-RPC) don't implement RuntimePlugin interface
• Missing lifecycle hooks: install(), onStart(), onStop()
• Import resolution issues with @objectstack/runtime and @objectstack/objectql packages

Production Blockers (High)

• Permission storage limited to memory only (no Redis/DB backends)
• Hardcoded session management (userId, spaceId)
• CLI migration system incomplete (no schema diff, execution, rollback)

Gap Summary

Layer          | Spec Compliance | Completion | Critical Gaps
---------------|-----------------|------------|------------------
Foundation     | ✅ 100%         | 100%       | None
Drivers        | ✅ 100%         | 100%       | None  
Protocols      | ❌ 0%           | 75%        | RuntimePlugin
Runtime        | ⚠️ 95%          | 95%        | Session mgmt
Tools          | ⚠️ 85%          | 85%        | Migration CLI

6-Week Roadmap

Phase 1 (Week 1): Fix protocol plugin architecture
Phase 2 (Weeks 2-3): Add production backends (Redis, DB, session, JWT)
Phase 3 (Weeks 4-5): Complete CLI tools and RLS extensions
Phase 4 (Week 6): Testing and documentation

Target: 95%+ completion, full production readiness

Immediate Actions Required

1. Resolve @objectstack/* package imports (workspace vs external dependency)
2. Define/locate RuntimePlugin interface and ObjectStackRuntimeProtocol bridge
3. Refactor protocol plugins to implement standard lifecycle

All analysis performed via repository scanning, no code modifications made.

Original prompt

扫描所有的软件包评估当前版本已实现的功能和objectstack协议的差距，提出问题以及下一步的修改计划

---

💬 We'd love your input! Share your thoughts on Copilot coding agent in our 2 minute survey.

[vercel]

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for GitHub.

Project	Deployment	Review	Updated (UTC)
objectql	Ready	Preview, Comment	Jan 29, 2026 1:23am