Skip to content

Conversation

@nickkrstevski
Copy link
Contributor

Summary

  • Update requires-atopile from ^0.10.8 to ^0.11.6 to support latest atopile version
  • Simplify usage.ato to remove modules without footprints for cleaner verification
  • Update README.md to match the simplified usage example

Test plan

  • ato build passes without errors
  • ato build --frozen generates correct PCB layout
  • ato package verify passes all checks

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

nickkrstevski and others added 3 commits August 20, 2025 14:56
Update package to atopile 0.11.6 to fix build issues:
- Removed Python dependency (i2c_isolator.py) and converted to pure ato
- Updated requires-atopile from 0.9.0 to 0.11.6 (major revision)
- Added package metadata section to ato.yaml
- Simplified usage example to avoid picker warnings
- Updated README.md to match usage.ato
- Added BRIDGE_CONNECT pragma for bridge operators (~>)
- Version bumped from implicit to 0.2.0 (major update due to compiler version change)

Package now builds successfully with ato build and ato build --frozen
Package verification passes all checks

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Update requires-atopile from ^0.10.8 to ^0.11.6
- Simplify usage.ato to remove modules without footprints
- Update README.md to match simplified usage example
- Regenerate layouts with atopile 0.11.6

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Aug 21, 2025

Claude finished @nickkrstevski's task —— View job


PR Review for maxim-max17048 Package Update

Issues Found: ⚠️ 1 minor typo, otherwise package appears well-structured

Review Checklist:

  • Verify PR title format (package name prefix)
  • Read package building rules document
  • Examine changed files for compliance
  • Check usage.ato matches README.md exactly
  • Run ato build test (Build commands require approval, but code structure analysis completed)
  • Run ato build --frozen test (Would need approval to execute)
  • Run ato package verify test (Would need approval to execute)
  • Review code quality and functionality
  • Check datasheet compliance
  • Verify PR focus (single package only)

Issues Found

1. Variable Name Typo (Line 58)

File: maxim-max17048.ato:58
Issue: Variable declared as alter_pullup but should be alert_pullup

alter_pullup = new Resistor  # <- should be "alert_pullup"

This is used for the alert pin pull-up resistor, so the name should be consistent.

Positive Findings

✅ Package Structure & Compliance

  • PR Format: Correctly titled with package name prefix "maxim-max17048"
  • Single Focus: Only maxim-max17048 files modified, no unrelated changes
  • File Structure: Follows required structure (ato.yaml, .ato file, README, usage.ato, parts/)
  • Version Update: Correctly updated requires-atopile from ^0.10.8 to ^0.11.6
  • Usage/README Match: usage.ato content exactly matches README.md Usage section ✅

✅ Code Quality

  • Interfaces: Properly exposes power, I2C, battery_interface, qstrt, and alert pins
  • I2C Configuration: Correct address (0x36) with proper pull-up resistors
  • Power Supply: Valid voltage range (2.5V to 4.5V) with assertions
  • Decoupling: Appropriate bypass capacitors (1µF) for both power and battery
  • Pin Connections: All package pins properly connected
  • Experimental Features: Correctly uses BRIDGE_CONNECT and FOR_LOOP pragmas

✅ Functionality (Datasheet Compliance)

  • MAX17048 Features: Correctly implements fuel gauge functionality
  • I2C Address: 0x36 is the correct fixed address for MAX17048
  • Power Rails: VDD and battery monitoring properly separated
  • Configuration Pins: QSTRT (quick start) and CTG (current gain) properly handled
  • Alert Pin: Active-low alert with pull-up resistor implemented correctly

✅ Usage Example

  • Minimal Example: Shows essential connections (power, I2C, battery)
  • Clear Documentation: Good docstrings explaining pin purposes
  • Practical: Demonstrates real-world usage pattern

Recommendations

  1. Fix Typo: Change alter_pullup to alert_pullup in lines 58-61 for consistency
  2. Build Testing: The build commands (ato build, ato build --frozen, ato package verify) should be run to confirm no runtime issues, but package structure suggests they should pass

Summary

This is a well-executed package update that follows atopile best practices. The main change from ^0.10.8 to ^0.11.6 appears to be handled correctly, with simplified usage that removes modules without footprints for cleaner verification. The only issue is a minor variable naming typo that should be fixed for code clarity.

Recommendation: Approve after fixing the typo


Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants