Skip to content

Conversation

@Helmi
Copy link
Owner

@Helmi Helmi commented Sep 12, 2025

Summary

Changes

  • Added missing apply_command_replacement() call in Bash command processing (line 886)
  • Fixed apply_command_replacement() function to properly handle "running " format
  • Added default replacements for "gh" → "github CLI" and "uv" → "U V"
  • Fixed function logic to preserve original command structure when no replacement found

Test Plan

  • Verified command replacements work for common commands (gh, uvx, uv, npm, etc.)
  • Confirmed existing functionality remains intact
  • Tested both direct command replacements and pattern matching

Closes #11

- Add missing apply_command_replacement() call for Bash commands
- Fix apply_command_replacement() to preserve full command structure
- Add default replacements for gh (github CLI) and uv (U V)
- Handle both "running <cmd>" format and direct command replacements

Fixes #11
@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Sep 12, 2025

Claude finished @Helmi's task —— View job


PR Review Complete ✅

Review Tasks:

  • Read and analyze the changed file (src/ccnotify/notify.py)
  • Evaluate code quality and best practices
  • Check for potential bugs or logic issues
  • Assess security concerns
  • Review performance considerations
  • Evaluate test coverage completeness
  • Provide comprehensive feedback

Code Review Feedback

Overall Assessment

This PR successfully addresses the missing apply_command_replacement() call for Bash TTS notifications. The implementation is sound and follows the existing codebase patterns well.

🔧 Code Quality & Best Practices

Strengths:

  • Consistent with existing code patterns - The fix follows the same approach used elsewhere in the codebase
  • Well-structured logic - The apply_command_replacement() function properly handles both "running " patterns and direct command replacements
  • Good error handling - Function gracefully returns original text when no replacement is found
  • Appropriate placement - The fix is correctly placed at line 896 within the Bash command processing logic

Areas for improvement:

  • Consider adding type hints to the apply_command_replacement() function parameters for better code documentation
  • The function could benefit from a docstring explaining the "running" prefix behavior

🐛 Bug Analysis

Fixed Issues:

  • Primary bug resolved - Commands like "gh", "uvx", "uv" now correctly apply replacements in TTS
  • Pattern matching works - Both direct command replacements and regex patterns are properly applied
  • Preserves structure - The fix maintains the original command structure when no replacement is found

No new bugs identified - The implementation is safe and follows defensive programming practices.

🔒 Security Assessment

No security concerns identified:

  • The function only processes text replacements for TTS pronunciation
  • No external API calls or file system operations
  • Input sanitization is appropriate for the use case
  • No risk of command injection or other security vulnerabilities

Performance Considerations

Efficient implementation:

  • Minimal overhead - The function uses simple string operations and regex matching
  • Early returns - Logic uses early returns to avoid unnecessary processing
  • Cached patterns - Regex patterns are loaded once from configuration
  • No performance regressions - The fix only adds one function call to existing logic

🧪 Test Coverage Evaluation

Test Plan Analysis:

  • Manual testing completed - PR author verified command replacements work for common commands
  • Regression testing - Confirmed existing functionality remains intact
  • Pattern testing - Both direct and pattern matching tested

Suggestions for enhanced testing:

  • Consider adding unit tests for the apply_command_replacement() function
  • Edge case testing could include empty strings, special characters, and very long commands

📝 Specific Code Comments

Line 896 - src/ccnotify/notify.py:896:

audio_desc = apply_command_replacement(audio_desc, replacements)

Perfect placement - This is exactly where the call needed to be added to fix the TTS pronunciation issue.

Lines 597-616 - src/ccnotify/notify.py:597-616:
The logic for handling "running " format is well-implemented:

  • Correctly identifies "running" prefix
  • Preserves command structure
  • Handles both cases (with and without "running" prefix)

🎯 Final Recommendations

Ready to merge with minor enhancements:

  1. Consider adding a unit test for apply_command_replacement() to prevent future regressions
  2. Optional: Add type hints to improve code documentation
  3. Optional: Add docstring explaining the function's behavior with "running" prefix

This PR effectively resolves issue #11 and improves the user experience for TTS notifications without introducing any risks or breaking changes.


@Helmi Helmi merged commit aa67f71 into main Sep 12, 2025
1 check passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Command replacements not applied to Bash commands for TTS

2 participants