Shadi A.

[shmoonwalker]

Complete Task 1

[mvcatsifma]

Clean and well-structured submission with good input validation and some nice defensive coding touches, especially readIntInRange(), getModuleName() bounds checking, and returning grades.clone() for encapsulation.

Main improvement areas:

• The project currently does not run due to the package/setup issue (Main.java missing package com.hyfacademy; combined with the flat directory structure). Always run and test the application before submitting.
• The average calculation currently includes ungraded modules (0 values), which unfairly lowers the student average.
• Public methods are missing Javadoc comments.
• Formatting and indentation are inconsistent in several places.

For future assignments:

• Always compile and run the project before submission.
• Validate calculation logic against edge cases like partially graded students.
• Add Javadoc for public methods and utility classes.
• Use an auto-formatter to keep formatting consistent.

Good overall effort and solid Week 1 progress.

[shmoonwalker]

Clean and well-structured submission with good input validation and some nice defensive coding touches, especially readIntInRange(), getModuleName() bounds checking, and returning grades.clone() for encapsulation.

Main improvement areas:

• The project currently does not run due to the package/setup issue (Main.java missing package com.hyfacademy; combined with the flat directory structure). Always run and test the application before submitting.
• The average calculation currently includes ungraded modules (0 values), which unfairly lowers the student average.
• Public methods are missing Javadoc comments.
• Formatting and indentation are inconsistent in several places.

For future assignments:

• Always compile and run the project before submission.
• Validate calculation logic against edge cases like partially graded students.
• Add Javadoc for public methods and utility classes.
• Use an auto-formatter to keep formatting consistent.

Good overall effort and solid Week 1 progress.

Hey Thomas. thank you for reviewing my code. i used vim in first two week for codes thats why its not well formatted .also no idea what is Javadoc but i will try to write comments for my functions from now on. also i run the project again and for me its working
i made change in calculateAverage method as well.
thanks a lot