Skip to content

Request exact splits for remaining benchmarks, especially SpreadsheetBench #21

@LifeIsSoSolong

Description

@LifeIsSoSolong

Hi SkillOpt team,

Thank you for the quick response in #14 and for sharing the SearchQA split IDs. That is very helpful for reproducing the SearchQA experiments.

Could you also share the exact split details for the remaining benchmarks, especially SpreadsheetBench?

We tried a protocol-level reproduction on SpreadsheetBench using the official SpreadsheetBench data artifact:

Since the exact SkillOpt SpreadsheetBench split is not currently available, we created a deterministic random split from the Verified 400 set:

  • train=80
  • selection/validation=40
  • test=280
  • random seed: 42

Then we ran two no-skill test baselines with gpt-5.4-nano as the target model:

Optimizer Target Local no-skill test baseline
gpt-5.4-nano gpt-5.4-nano 36.1
gpt-5.5 gpt-5.4-nano 36.8

These are both much higher than the SpreadsheetBench gpt-5.4-nano baseline reported in the paper Table 5 (23.5). On our random split, the cell-level baseline is close to that number (23.8), while the sheet-level baseline is much higher (63.2 / 65.5), so the overall score seems quite sensitive to the exact split, task composition, and/or aggregation details.

Would it be possible to share:

  1. The exact train/selection/test split manifests or stable task IDs for SpreadsheetBench.
  2. The same split manifests for the other benchmarks (OfficeQA, DocVQA, LiveMathematicianBench, and ALFWorld), if available.
  3. Any preprocessing/filtering scripts used to construct those splits.
  4. For SpreadsheetBench specifically, whether the reported score is a plain item-level average over the test split, a macro average over task types, or uses any filtering beyond the public Verified 400 artifact.

Thanks again for making the SearchQA split available.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions