Rule blocked: GC0019

[mhungria]

Executing with the CLI 0.12.0 on a Mac:
python3 core.py validate -s sdtmig -v 3-4 -dv 2-1 -dxp .../subset/define_msg20_testsupp_core.xml -d .../subset --output .../subset/results/gc0019_draft_results --output-format JSON --output-format XLSX -lr .../subset/draft_rules -r CDISC.SDTMIG.CG0019 -l error &> .../subset_execution_errors.txt

The attached zip includes the subset of source json files, define_msg20_testsupp_core.xml file, the draft rule and the results of the above execution:
subset.zip
Plus execution errors:
subset_execution_errors.txt
From the define_msg20_testsupp_core.xml in the zip attached:

Bugs and expected behavior

• 1. Execution errors attached. I would expect no execution errors, all issues reported as CG0019 duplicates.
• 2. the define_dataset_key_sequence variable doesn't include the key specified for EC from SUPPEC, per the Define-XML document referenced. See output files attached. I would expect to see the last key in SUPPEC.ECREASOC
• 3. it appears that supp* datasets are not individually considered to report duplicate key issues (as a standard SUPPQUAL structure). I would expect issues reported for SUPPDM and SUPPEC separately.
• 4. got execution error for RELREC. I would expect an issue reported for RELREC as it has a duplicate row based on its define keys.

Links to related JIRA Tickets

• https://jira.cdisc.org/browse/CORERULES-11
  Links to related github Tickets
• Rule blocked: CORERULES-11 - merge parents with supps #345 (appears as closed).
• Recommendation to add a dataset_is_custom operation to clearly separate from domain_is_custom #1329

Rule Information

• Standard: SDTMIG, testing with 3.4; however, should bbe applicable to any standard, any version
• Rule ID: CG0019 (CDISC.SDTMIG.CG0019)
• Rule Description: Trigger error if records are not unique as per sponsor defined key variables as documented in the define.xml

[mhungria]

Hi Team,

I repeated a few tests for CG0019. See the complete list of Bugs and expected behavior in the ticket information above:
Bugs and expected behavior
Execution errors attached. I would expect no execution errors, all issues reported as CG0019 duplicates.

Rule Editor
SUPPEC results look ok now; however, I am getting execution error for EC.
Note: the key specified for EC includes SUPPEC.ECREASOC (see the define.xml document enclosed)
Source and results in this zip file:
Rule_CG0019_ruleeditor_results.zip

CLI v0.13.0, executing on a Linux box.
SUPPEC results look ok now; however, no issues reported for EC.
Source EC and SUPPEC below, define.xml same as in the zip file.
ecx4.json
suppecx4.json
core_val_cg0019.json

Regards,
Marcelina

[mhungria]

Hi @SFJohnson24 , what release would have all the fixes for this ticket?