-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 11
Open
Description
Epic add these suggestions from this PR:
Pull Request #72: Comprehensive Unit Tests for PNodeData
This pull request introduces configuration management for the pWord Windows Forms application and enhances the testing framework for its components.
- Configuration Services: Automatically configures Windows Forms controls from
app.configsettings. - Enhanced Testing: Converts placeholder tests into functional tests with proper error handling.
- Test Infrastructure: Adds configuration management, mock data creation, and testing documentation.
File Changes Summary
- pWordLib.csproj: Added
System.Configurationreference. - pWordLib/*.cs: Implemented new configuration services.
- Test_WindowsForms/*.cs: Added comprehensive Windows Forms tests.
- Test_WindowsForms/app.config: Provided configuration values for testing form controls.
- WindowsFormsTests.cs: Transformed placeholder tests into functional validation tests.
- obj/*: Removed generated build artifacts.
AI Code Review Feedback
1. ToolBarConfigurationService.cs
- Issue: Using
Convert.ChangeTypewithout type checking can cause runtime exceptions. - Suggestion: Implement a safer conversion method to prevent crashes.
var convertedValue = SafeConvert(value, property.PropertyType); if (convertedValue != null) property.SetValue(toolBar, convertedValue);
2. WindowsFormsTests.cs
- Issue: Invoking private methods with reflection is fragile and difficult to maintain.
- Suggestion: Use a public API to trigger the
Loadevent instead.// Simulate load event using public API form.CreateControl(); // This will fire the Load event
3. ConfigurationDetectionService.cs
- Issue: Direct casting without type validation can cause an
InvalidCastException. - Suggestion: Add type checking and a
try-catchblock for safer conversion.var rawValue = _configReader.GetValue(key, typeof(T)); if (rawValue is T typedValue) { _configCache[key] = typedValue; return typedValue; } else { // Try to convert if possible try { var convertedValue = (T)Convert.ChangeType(rawValue, typeof(T)); _configCache[key] = convertedValue; return convertedValue; } catch { return defaultValue; } }
4. WindowsFormsTests.cs
- Issue: The code saves a BMP file but uses an
.icofile extension, which is misleading. - Suggestion: Use the correct method to create and save a true icon (
.ico) file.// Save as icon (correct approach) using (var icon = Icon.FromHandle(bitmap.GetHicon())) using (var fs = new FileStream(iconPath, FileMode.Create)) { icon.Save(fs); }
PR Status
- Status: 🚧 Draft - This pull request is a work in progress.
- Reviews: 1 approving review is required to merge.
- Checks: 🔴 2 checks failing, 1 cancelled.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels