Skip to content

EPIC: Create new issues for these suggestions for testing from this PR #73

@marcnoon

Description

@marcnoon

Epic add these suggestions from this PR:

Pull Request #72: Comprehensive Unit Tests for PNodeData

This pull request introduces configuration management for the pWord Windows Forms application and enhances the testing framework for its components.

  • Configuration Services: Automatically configures Windows Forms controls from app.config settings.
  • Enhanced Testing: Converts placeholder tests into functional tests with proper error handling.
  • Test Infrastructure: Adds configuration management, mock data creation, and testing documentation.

File Changes Summary

  • pWordLib.csproj: Added System.Configuration reference.
  • pWordLib/*.cs: Implemented new configuration services.
  • Test_WindowsForms/*.cs: Added comprehensive Windows Forms tests.
  • Test_WindowsForms/app.config: Provided configuration values for testing form controls.
  • WindowsFormsTests.cs: Transformed placeholder tests into functional validation tests.
  • obj/*: Removed generated build artifacts.

AI Code Review Feedback

1. ToolBarConfigurationService.cs

  • Issue: Using Convert.ChangeType without type checking can cause runtime exceptions.
  • Suggestion: Implement a safer conversion method to prevent crashes.
    var convertedValue = SafeConvert(value, property.PropertyType);
    if (convertedValue != null)
        property.SetValue(toolBar, convertedValue);

2. WindowsFormsTests.cs

  • Issue: Invoking private methods with reflection is fragile and difficult to maintain.
  • Suggestion: Use a public API to trigger the Load event instead.
    // Simulate load event using public API
    form.CreateControl(); // This will fire the Load event

3. ConfigurationDetectionService.cs

  • Issue: Direct casting without type validation can cause an InvalidCastException.
  • Suggestion: Add type checking and a try-catch block for safer conversion.
    var rawValue = _configReader.GetValue(key, typeof(T));
    if (rawValue is T typedValue) {
        _configCache[key] = typedValue;
        return typedValue;
    } else {
        // Try to convert if possible
        try {
            var convertedValue = (T)Convert.ChangeType(rawValue, typeof(T));
            _configCache[key] = convertedValue;
            return convertedValue;
        } catch {
            return defaultValue;
        }
    }

4. WindowsFormsTests.cs

  • Issue: The code saves a BMP file but uses an .ico file extension, which is misleading.
  • Suggestion: Use the correct method to create and save a true icon (.ico) file.
    // Save as icon (correct approach)
    using (var icon = Icon.FromHandle(bitmap.GetHicon()))
    using (var fs = new FileStream(iconPath, FileMode.Create))
    {
        icon.Save(fs);
    }

PR Status

  • Status: 🚧 Draft - This pull request is a work in progress.
  • Reviews: 1 approving review is required to merge.
  • Checks: 🔴 2 checks failing, 1 cancelled.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions